Our Blog

Is Paying a Financial Advisor Worth It?

Is Paying a Financial Advisor Worth it Compared to DIY Investing in the S&P 500?

A common and fair question we often get is: “Why pay a financial advisor a fee when I could simply invest in the S&P 500 index?” While fees vary depending on assets, let’s use 1% as an example. On the surface, the S&P 500 boasts a strong track record, making that 1% advisory fee seem like an unnecessary drag on returns.

However, long-term investing is more than picking a fund or chasing trends. It’s about staying disciplined during market volatility, understanding your full financial picture, and making informed decisions aligned with your aspirations. That 1% financial advisor fee isn’t just for portfolio management: it’s an investment in a comprehensive partnership to navigate your financial life.

Why Investors Compare Financial Advisors to the S&P 500

The comparison between hiring a financial advisor and investing in the S&P 500 is natural. The index offers a straightforward, often cost-effective way to gain diversified market exposure. Many see S&P 500 investing as a simple “set it and forget it” approach of passive investing vs active management. This prompts the question: Is a financial advisor worth it, given this seemingly simple alternative? We aim to answer this by revealing the true value of a financial advisor beyond just market returns.

More Than Market Returns: The Hidden Value of a Financial Advisor

While the S&P 500 is a strong benchmark, it’s also volatile and concentrated in the larger stocks within the index. When markets dip, panic often sets in. During these times, the temptation to sell is overwhelming, leading to devastating emotional investing mistakes. This is where a financial advisor truly shines. A significant part of your 1% advisory fee covers guidance that helps you to remain calm and focused when markets are tumultuous.

As we often tell clients, “Money is emotional—part of our value is to help take emotions out of the decision-making process.” Panic selling or irrational exuberance can severely erode long-term wealth accumulation. It’s often not the markets that destroy returns but the reactive decisions people make. A dedicated financial advisor provides a steady hand, a rational perspective, and historical context to avoid costly pitfalls. As your financial anchor, we ensure you stay focused on your long-term financial objectives.

Tailored Advice vs. One-Size-Fits-All Portfolios

Investing in the S&P 500 is a one-size-fits-all approach to a deeply personal financial journey. Your life, goals, risk tolerance, and timelines are unique. That 1% financial advisor fee is also for building a meticulously crafted financial blueprint that fits your life and aspirations.

At Fort Pitt Capital Group, we delve deep to understand your goals, whether they involve retirement planning, your children’s education, or leaving a legacy. This goes beyond asset allocation. It involves identifying tax-saving investment strategies, addressing estate planning considerations, and managing risk in investing that doesn’t show up on a stock chart. A good financial advisor connects strong financial ideas with your money, ensuring your investment portfolio grows strategically towards your unique future. Additionally, a good advisor will consider using a diversified portfolio of stocks, bonds, alternative investments, and cash to help you achieve your personalized goals while considering risk tolerance.

Long-Term Wealth: More Than Just Staying Invested

The adage holds true: “It’s not about timing the market; it’s about time in the market.” While the S&P 500 generally trends upwards in the long term, the challenge for individuals is to stay consistently invested through both up and down markets. Many investors buy high and sell low, trying to time the market instead of committing to a long-term investment strategy.

A competent financial advisor helps you grow wealth; an exceptional one helps you keep it and allows it to compound. For most of our clients, the main goal is to maintain and/or grow wealth, not get rich. We provide oversight and ongoing adjustments to keep your comprehensive financial planning on track, optimizing your “time in the market.” We monitor your portfolio, adjust as life changes, and proactively identify opportunities and threats.

What That Fee Really Covers

When considering paying a financial advisor, it’s important to understand the breadth of services.

• Personalized Financial Planning: Tailoring your financial blueprint.
• Behavioral Coaching: Preventing emotional investing mistakes during market volatility.
• Tax-Efficient Investing: Optimizing after-tax returns via tax-saving strategies.
• Estate & Risk Management Guidance: Integrating investments with broader estate planning and assessing financial risks.
• Ongoing Monitoring: Continuously adjusting your plan as markets or life changes.
• Expert Access & Peace of Mind: Providing insights and the comfort of professional management.

 

This holistic approach answers the question, “How much value does a financial advisor provide?” far beyond a passive index fund.

Partnering for Your Financial Future

So, yes, you could invest on your own and save that 1% advisory fee. However, what could that cost you in the long term? The real cost isn’t just potential lower returns from emotional investing decisions or missed opportunities; it’s the invaluable financial advisor peace of mind, clarity, and strategic wealth management a dedicated financial advisor provides. Just as you consult a qualified doctor for the best medical advice or a skilled mechanic for expert auto advice, managing your complex financial future often benefits most from a qualified financial professional.

At Fort Pitt Capital Group, we build enduring relationships based on trust and a shared vision for your financial future. We don’t just manage money; we manage your entire financial journey, helping you navigate complex markets with confidence and clarity. Let us be your partner in financial planning and turn your financial aspirations into reality. If comprehensive, disciplined stewardship is important, “Should I hire a financial advisor?” The answer is clear.

Ready to take control of your financial future?

Contact us to connect with a financial advisor specializing in your specific needs—get in touch and see what we can do for you.

About the Author

Lyle is a founding Partner of Telemus, a division of Kovitz Investment Group, which operates under the umbrella of Focus Financial Partners. He is responsible for managing some of the firm’s most significant client relationships. With over 30 years of experience in financial wealth planning and investment management, Lyle brings a deep understanding of the industry, shaped by his previous roles as a Financial Advisor at Merrill Lynch and a Senior Vice President–Investments at UBS Financial Services.

 

 

Kovitz Investment Group Partners, LLC (“Kovitz”) DBA Fort Pitt Capital Group. Fort Pitt Capital Group is a division of Kovitz, a registered investment adviser with the Securities and Exchange Commission. SEC registration does not constitute an endorsement of the firm by the Commission nor does it indicate that the adviser has attained a particular level of skill or ability.

The information included herein may contain statements related to future events or developments that may constitute forward-looking statements. These statements may be in the form of financial projections and may be identified by words such as “expectation”. “anticipate”, “could”, “estimate”, “will”, “should” or similar terms. Such statements are based on the current expectations and certain assumptions of the author and are, therefore, subject to certain risks and uncertainties.

The description of products, services, and performance results of Kovitz contained herein is not an offering or a solicitation of any kind. Past performance is not an indication of future results. Securities investments are subject to risk and may lose value.